Personal Guarantees – a note of caution


Personal Guarantees – a note of caution

Personal Guarantees are used as a way of overcoming concerns regarding future events, but it is never something to be taken lightly. It is important that a person providing a personal guarantee understands its full implications before agreeing to it. Obtaining independent legal advice should always be recommended.

NAI Blog

What is a personal guarantee?

A personal guarantee is an individual’s legal promise to ensure that a person or entity will perform a contractual obligation to a third party. If that person or entity fails to perform the contractual obligation, the individual providing the guarantee must step in and perform the obligation.

Some common examples of situations where personal guarantees are required are:

  • A company entering into a lease as a tenant;
  • A company obtaining funding from a third party;
  • A company supplying products to another company prior to payment being received.

A recent case study from the High Court

The facts
In a matter before the High Court, one of three directors of a company [Company A] signed a personal guarantee to a supplier company [Company Z], personally requesting Company Z supply Company A with orders it required and in consideration of that supply, he [Mr M from Company A] personally undertook to pay the amount payable upon demand.

Five years after entering into the agreement, Company A fell behind with payments. Company Z sought payment from Company A. In that correspondence, Company Z mentioned Mr M’s guarantee.

A payment plan was arranged, but within the year Company A had fallen behind with its payments.

Another payment plan was arranged, but Company Z advised that it would pursue Mr M personally if the payments were not met. At that time, the outstanding amount was approximately $160,000.

One month later, Mr M resigned as a director of Company A. At this point the outstanding amount was nearly $170,000.

Shortly after Mr M’s resignation, one of the directors from Company Z visited him to check on his well-being. Mr M explained that he had resigned because to have remained with Company A would have been detrimental to its ability to reduce debt and he did not now consider he was responsible for debt going forward. Company Z’s director [Mr F] apparently said something along the lines of “Not to worry about it”.

The second payment plan did not assist and within another two months the outstanding debt was approximately $270,000.

At this point, Company Z lost patience. It sent a letter of demand to Mr M under the guarantee requesting payment of approximately $270,000 within 7 days.

Mr M responded explaining that he was no longer a director or an employee of Company A. Not surprisingly, Company Z responded by pointing out the fact that this did not hinder it from calling on the personal guarantee.

Shortly thereafter, Company A was placed into liquidation. Company Z pursued its claim against Mr M.

The defence
Mr M argued that he had been naive in signing the agreement and if he had been aware it was made in his personal capacity, and not on behalf of Company A, he would never have signed it. He also argued that one of the other directors of the Company had directed him to sign it.

Mr M also suggested that he had received a partial release from the guarantee from Company Z’s Mr F on the basis that when he had explained to Mr F that he was not going to stay with the Company so as not to be detrimental to repayment of debt going forward, Mr F said “not to worry about it”.

The decision
The Court said that the law was clear and if obligations guaranteed are not satisfied, the guarantor must satisfy them to the extent of the terms of the guarantee. It said however that a continuing guarantee, such as the one in this transaction, could be released or revoked in respect of liability to accrue in the future.

The court agreed that a release from such a guarantee can be effective orally, although also noted written notice was wise.

However, it considered that in this case the proposition that the guarantee was released or varied by Mr F was not supported by the evidence as:

a) Mr F was adamant that the words “don’t worry about it” did not relate to the guarantee;
b) There was no contemporaneous documentation to suggest Mr F had released the guarantee; and
c) Mr M did not mention the release when it responded to Company Z’s demand on the guarantee.

The Court concluded that Mr M was liable under the personal guarantee for the $270,000.

Further, the fact that Mr M had resigned from the Company did not release him or act as a partial release from the guarantee.

Conclusion
Personal guarantees can come in many shapes and sizes. It is important to ensure you and receive adequate legal advice on contracts, and particularly on the potential impact of any personal guarantees included in those contracts.

By Shyrelle Mitchell, Partner, Heaney & Partners

This article featured in NAI Harcourts’ Key Assets magazine issue 3, 2019.
View the latest e-book and subscribe to future issues:

LEARN MORE

Industry Update,

NAI Harcourts,

Commercial Property,

Key Assets,

business broking,

harcourts new zealand

Popular Listings

  • Practical Trade Unit
    Highly functional office/warehouse unit available for lease. The space is currently configured with shop front, bi-folding doors set inside the roller door at the entrance of the Warehouse. If the bi-folds suit your business that's great! But if not, they can easily be removed, thus reverting the space back to its original intended use as a Warehouse. Key Features: - 72m² warehouse - Mezzanine office (30m²) - Roller door / bi fold doors - Two allocated car parks Call the sole agents at NAI Harcourts today.
  • Takapuna Retail Showroom and Warehouse
    Situated in the heart of sought after Barrys Point Road in Takapuna, these large retail showroom, warehouse and office premises totalling approx. 1,462m² are available on a new lease from 1st August 2020. Offering wide street frontage with excellent exposure and large front yard for display purposes or customer parking this building has been occupied for the last 10 years as a successful Motorcycle Dealership providing sales, accessories and service facilities. Comprising retail showroom of approx 524m², mezzanine office 186m² and warehousing and storage of 752m² the premises include 6 car parks on the front yard, further 9 at the rear and option for additional basement car parks. Only 3 minutes north of the Harbour Bridge, Barrys Point Road is home to many outdoor sports, trade retail, automotive, furniture and service retail type uses. Call now to arrange an inspection of this exceptional opportunity.
  • High Profile Wairau Warehouse / Showroom 916.72m²
    Now available! This 916.72m² (approx) high-stud warehouse / showroom is one not to be missed. Located in the heart of the Wairau Valley, the site makes for an ideal trade or bulk retail location. Featuring a highly flexible open plan layout, the high stud warehouse can be configured to provide as much showroom and warehouse as your business requires. Retail access is at the front and full height roller door at the rear. Adjacent to the roller door is a designated container drop off area. Access is a dream and is complemented well by the use of 14 dedicated carparks plus half share of an additional 22! Be where the action is! Direct neighbours include Mitre 10 Mega, Pak'n Save and Bunnings Warehouse. The site has fantastic exposure to Wairau Road and great signage opportunity. Motorway access is only 800m down the road at the Tristram Avenue interchange. Approximate Area Breakdown: Breakdown: - Warehouse / showroom - 710.69 - Office and amenities - 206.03 - Car parks (dedicated) - 14 car parks - Car parks (half-share) - 22 car parks Call the joint sole agents at NAI Harcourts today.
  • Vibrant Wairau Business Hub Development
    Stage 1 resource consent obtained - Sept 2019 Huge potential for Childcare, Pharmacy, Entertainment, Medical GP's & Specialists (e.g. Chiropractors, Physios), Dentists, Gym, Pilates, Yoga, Restaurant/Cafes, Offices etc*, to be strategically located within this exciting development. Flexible tenancy sizes range from 100m² to over 1000m². The site offers elevated, road front profile, within the Wairau Valley's growth corridor. Large format food retail premises are scheduled for development next door and the Southern Cross Hospital is just around the corner. Ample parking - 90 car parks. Accessible location - 1 minute from SH1 on-ramps at Tristram Avenue. Completion due early 2021. The developer is now inviting expressions of interest. Call NAI Harcourts today to discuss your requirements and secure premises in this exciting development. (* Subject to resource consent)
  • A-grade Industrial Investment – New 10 Year Lease
    Finally, a stunning standalone Industrial investment worthy of your attention. Taking pride of place on the ever-popular Apollo Drive on Auckland's North Shore, this prize asset offers a new 10-year lease to its anchor tenant and will sit proudly in your portfolio. Currently occupied by RPM International Tool & Die Limited as well as Mitre 10 New Zealand Limited, the contract rentals combine to $492,080 pa plus GST plus outgoings. Situated on a high profile freehold site with wide street frontage, the building was purpose built to allow for future growth of RPM, but also allows for a split tenancy arrangement which is currently in place. With an A-grade seismic rating of 92% and a warehouse stud height of 7.8 - 9 metres, the quality of the asset is on par with new builds, but in a sought after location. Warehouse construction is full height pre-cast concrete tilt-slab panels and the main offices at the front of the building are fully air conditioned. Opportunities of this calibre rarely come to the open market. Please call one of the preferred joint sole agents today for further information or to arrange an inspection. Key Features: - Freehold site of 5,160m² (more or less) - Total building area of 3,368m² (approx.) - A-grade seismic rating of 92% - New 10 year lease to anchor tenant from 1st June 2020 - Dual tenancy providing for future expansion - Zoned General Business - 53 car parks onsite - Combined contract rental of $492,080 pa plus GST plus outgoings. For sale by Deadline Private Treaty (unless sold prior) Closing 4.00pm, Thursday 2nd July 2020 To download further information please copy and paste this link into your browser: http://www.propertyfiles.co.nz/property/NSC34249 NOTE: all outlines in images are indicative only
  • Affordable Devonport Office
    Positioned in the heart of Devonport are a variety of professional office options. Access via a stairway in the central lane way courtyard leading to the first floor office suites. Each office features a kitchenette, pitched ceilings and air-conditioning. The offices are within close proximity to a number of eateries and retailers along with just a short walk to recently redeveloped Devonport Wharf. Features: - Car parking available - Character brick arcade - Close proximity to Devonport wharf - Through access to Wynyard Street - Air-conditioned - Short term lease available to the right tenant - Available now Available Options: - Office 4: 52 m² Call the sole agents at NAI Harcourts for further information and an appointment today.